More Pages: south america Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100


The best, most readable summary available of the Andean past

Exceptionally powerful.

A monumental workThe author's description of Juan Peron is comprehensive and complex, and may therefore be best suited for someone already very familiar with Peron and contemporary Argentine history. If you are looking for a more brief and succinct historical rendering of Peron's career, you may want to look elsewhere, perhaps to JUAN AND EVA PERON by Clive Foss. My favorite biography of Juan Peron is PERON AND ENIGMAS OF ARGENTINA by Robert D. Crassweller. Crassweller explains in PERON AND THE ENIGMAS OF ARGENTINA that Peron was a product of the "Hispanic Creole" tradition, and that all his successes and failures can be seen within the context of that culture, and in many ways were *shaped* by that culture. In fact, Crassweller argues that Peron's real talent was his keen insight into the culture, his keen intuition in understanding how to reach out to and unify as many different segments of Argentina as possible. While Joseph Page does attempt to provide cultural insight, he does not succeed to the extent that Crassweller does.
Joseph Page comes to a conclusion that may surprise many: that Juan Peron was a pacifist at heart; "He steadfastly rejected violence as an open instrument of policy." Page also points out the irony that Peron, once considered by some as a "South American Hitler," would have never plunged or plundered his country into war, and that it was the men who ousted Peron who went on to kill thousands of people.


The three Perons - the 'social' workers of Argentina

Excellent! A must have for visiting Peru.Until I read John Crabtree's profile of Peru the best book out was Jane Holligan's FOCUS: Peru Though I still recommend Holligan's book (see my review) Crabtree's profile is more current (up to the first year of President Alejandro Toledo's term - 2001) and more sensitive to the plight of the poor and oppressed in Peru.
Excellent is Crabree's section "The Fight for Democracy". A must read for those who desire to understand the political forces that control Peru. His insight into the critical control that the IMF, WTO and IDB have over developing countries like Peru are eye opening. His sections on the economy and society are informative and succinct. The poor (54% of the society) struggle daily, living hand-to-mouth while the wealthy and powerful remain safe behind their walled fortress homes.
John Crabtree didn't excessively laud ex-president Fujimori terms in office, but neither was he excessively critical of Fujimori's dirty subterfuge, which recently has been disclosed. Nor was he critical of Fujimori's hatchet man Vladimiro Montesios. He states, "Categorizing Fujimori is not easy. By no means a traditional dictator, he was certainly no democrat. Rather, his regime was a hybrid of both elements."
As I write this review there are demonstrations in every city in Peru. In the streets of Cusco, the police, in their attempt to crush a demonstration, killed a teacher (28 May 2003). President Toledo, is suffering a massive crash in his approval ratings (from 84% after the election to 14% May 2003). The lowest approval rating ever given to a president.
This is a must read profile of Peru. John Crabtree's book, along with a good travel guide (Footprint Peru 4th ed. - see my review) should be in your suitcase before departure. Highly recommended


"From Incas to Inca Cola"---an excellent cultural historyThis is the place. It's always a pleasure to find a good basic book that gives you clear, well-written insights into a country or time you really knew only hazily before. That's why I was so glad to read PERU, by Dobyns and Doughty. Though I bought it back in 1983 in Australia, when the book was only seven years published, I didn't get around to reading it till just now. It is part of a series of Latin American Histories put out by Oxford University Press. The only other one I ever read, on Chile, by Brian Loveman, also stood out as excellent.
PERU gives an excellent overview of how that country's culture changed over time, from the ancient civilizations of the oases and highlands long before the Christian era, through the Inca Empire (that began just about a century before its collapse under the Spanish onslaught), to the colonial era and the end of European rule. Even though in the 19th century, the political confusion is reflected in a less Olympian overview from the authors, cultural change, as opposed to blow-by-blow political history, remains uppermost. It is always difficult to separate these culture and political history---one might quibble with the authors whether this or that was entirely necessary, but they provide a readable, interesting account (you can let some of the statistical paragraphs go unless you are collecting data). My edition of the book ends at 1975, before the return of democracy, the rise of Alan Garcia, Fujimori and Sendero Luminoso, and the subsequent fall of all three. There are many books on the Incas and the ancient Peruvian civilizations. Pizarro and the Conquest are also well-covered in literature. Overviews, to my knowledge, are scarce. Thus, while somewhat dated, PERU may be the best book in English on Peruvian cultural history as a whole. Inca Cola does not rate a mention, however, neither does Vargas Llosa.


Perú: nación de sobrevivientesEstablecer un eje interpretativo con validez en el largo plazo es el mayor reto en un proyecto de esta naturaleza. Ni las épicas incaica o pizarrista ni menos aún la lucha por la independencia funcionan más, advierte el autor, como los eventos fundacionales de una historia nacional. En la supervivencia misma de sus pobladores, en su voluntad e ingenio para levantarse de sucesivas devastaciones -de origen tanto humano como natural-, encuentra el profesor Klarén la clave de la larga duración peruana; una historia, según él, tan rica como dolorosa.
Varios siglos de supervivencia comunitaria hicieron del Tawantinsuyo el más efectivo proyecto estatal en la historia de los Andes. Verdadero triunfo sobre la fragmentación que de la geografía misma pareciera emanar. Su derrumbe, y la catástrofe demográfica que prosiguió supondría para las sociedades andinas una perecedera «desestructuración».
Con todo su poderío, no obstante, el orden colonial no logra imponer por completo los criterios de casta y segregación originalmente previstos. A ello, los futuros peruanos ofrecieron una terca resistencia, demostrando asimismo una distintiva capacidad para maximizar las oportunidades que las fisuras del poder colonial ofrecían. A lo largo del XVIII, la supervivencia deviene rebeldía.
Frente a la conciencia criolla forjada en la capital virreinal surge, en la sierra sur, una visión alternativa: recuperar la memoria incaica en la perspectiva de un programa nacional. Como nación, el Perú terminará construyéndose a contramano de la historia representada por los rebeldes de 1780: «lo criollo» como negación de «lo andino».
Tomando la iniciativa nuevamente, entre fines del XIX e inicios del XX, emprende la población andina un nuevo ciclo de confrontación: comunidades contra haciendas una vez más. En lo que queda del siglo la cuestión de la marginalidad indígena aparece como el gran telón de fondo de una historia cuyos cronistas oficiales insistieron en reducir a los avatares estatales y capitalinos: la «historia de Lima» como sustituto de la «historia del Perú».
Una verdadera revolución historiográfica, en curso desde los años 70, es lo que permite, subraya Klarén, esta drástica ampliación del marco histórico peruano. Una revolución basada en los aportes convergentes de investigadores peruanos (Pease, Burga, Flores Galindo, Manrique, Bonilla, entre otros) y extranjeros (Stern, Spalding, Jacobsen, Gootemberg), cuya obra individual hace posible la síntesis interpretativa ahora intentada por Klarén.
Pero es la historia misma de las últimas décadas la que convalida el esquema interpretativo elegido por Klaren: la emergencia de una sociedad de masas que, del «desborde popular» (Matos Mar) al «otro sendero» (De Soto), y de la insurrección senderista a la contra-isurrección rondera, decretaría la crisis final del país imaginado por los criollos de inicios del XIX.
La evolución política contemporánea, desde esta perspectiva, aparece como una sucesión de intentos por revertir la desestructuración y erigir andamiajes institucionales duraderos sobre las arenas movedizas de una historia irresuelta.
Si hay una lección importante a extraer de una historia construida así es aquella relativa a las hondas raíces de nuestra fragmentación, sustrato último de nuestra inveterada inestabilidad. Dictamen de la geografía y de la historia, que explica, en buena medida, nuestra tradición de caudillos, refundaciones sucesivas y precarios experimentos democráticos. Ni el país «enfermo» o «embrujado» que se ha querido ver, tampoco el país con futuro brillante per se. Una lección de humildad más bien es la que esta lectura sugiere, la apreciación de un derrotero que lejos de culminar en el panteón de los héroes encuentra en una milenaria vocación de supervivencia su clave última y su promesa. Un país de sobrevivientes, en suma, aún a la espera de una genuina reconciliación.


Excellent to understand this complex country.

Essential Reading

Detailed biographies of singers/musicians on old records!